ATP Template with bundler

Civil disputes


Answer

The refusal of B to give something borrowed from C back to C is not automatically theft. In some cases it might have to be resolved using the Civil Courts and you may need to see a solicitor for advice.

Example:

B borrows C's power drill. B keeps promising to return it, he does not intend to keep it and it is just left in the garage, but he doesn't get round to giving it back. If this is pure forgetfulness, which goes on for a fairly long period (despite reminders) it would not be theft. However, eventually there comes a point where C has been deprived of his property for so long that B has no excuse for not returning it (perhaps a year or more) and the Criminal Courts would consider he had stolen the drill.

If you have a problem with someone who has borrowed your property, keep a record of all the occasions you have asked for it back and then ask a solicitor to send a formal letter asking for the return of the property. If the property is still not returned, there may sufficient to justify making a complaint of theft to the police.

Every case will be different and it may be, for example, that the borrower claims the property was a gift. In circumstances like that, the police may not be willing to take action and you must to go to the Civil Courts to get your property back. In the case of a borrowed power drill this may not be economically worthwhile. Below is a brief summary of the offence of theft, it is not intended to be a comprehensive explanation.

Theft occurs when someone dishonestly appropriates (takes possession of or make use of exclusively for oneself/someone else without permission) some property that does not belong to him or her and treats it as his or her own and has no intention of returning the property to its rightful owner.

Examples:

B is walking along the street chatting on her mobile phone when C runs past and takes the phone from her hand and runs off with it.

B takes an item from the shelf of a shop and leaves the shop without paying for it (shoplifting).

 


Answer

If hired property has not been returned it will only be a theft in certain circumstances.

Example:

B hires a car from C for a week and fails to return it on the due date. This does not automatically constitute a theft. B must have somehow treated the car as if it was his own, sold it on or moved from the area and taken the car with him and in doing so permanently deprived C of the ownership of the car.

In many cases, hired property is returned late or there is some misunderstanding. This is likely to be a breach of contract. It is advisable to make some basic enquiries into the matter (or speak to a lawyer) prior to making a formal complaint to the police, so you can give them as much information about the circumstances as possible. There can be a fine line between a civil dispute and theft.

If you are in any doubt (once you have found out why the goods have not been returned), contact the police or a solicitor who will help to explain the law accordingly. A brief summary of theft is below; it is not intended as a comprehensive explanation.

Theft occurs when someone dishonestly appropriates (takes possession of or make use of exclusively for oneself/someone else without permission) some property that does not belong to him or her and treats it as his or her own and has no intention of returning the property to its rightful owner.


Answer

Lighting a bonfire on private land in itself is not illegal (although it can be if within 30 meters of a road - see SQ625), but the smoke created can be a statutory nuisance.

Lighting a bonfire can be illegal if a person lights a fire, or directs/permits such fire, on land and the fire/smoke injures, interrupts or endangers users of a highway/carriageway.

Otherwise, the smoke created by the fire can be a statutory nuisance, and the environmental health department of your local authority will be able to take action if the smoke is classed as a statutory nuisance. You need to record the details of who is lighting the fires, what time, what the effects were and your details.

If the fires are very irregular then it is unlikely that the council will take any action. The council can stop the person from committing a statutory nuisance and failure to comply can lead to prosecution.

Please see the links in Related Information for further details.


Answer

If the trespassers were on council land then the council will have the responsibility of removing it. If the rubbish is on private land then it will be the landowner's responsibility to remove the rubbish. The council will remove it; however there will be a charge.


Answer

Trespass is a civil matter and the police only have powers to remove trespassers in limited circumstances. For example, if there is a large group of trespassers and damage has been caused.


Answer

You need to return the item back to the shop and explain the situation to them.

The retailer will probably want to see the receipt as proof of purchase from the shop, but should exchange the item without too much difficulty.

If however this does not happen, then you should seek advice from the Citizens Advice. The Government also offers help and advice in the form of Consumer Direct on 08454 04 05 06 (certain regions only) and Trading Standards may also be able to help.


Answer

It is always best to agree a price for the repair beforehand but when this situation arises it becomes a civil dispute.

If you cannot resolve the issue with the repairer then you would need to seek advice from the Citizens Advice or alternatively a solicitor.

The Government also offers help and advice to consumers in the form of Consumer Direct Tel: 08454 04 05 06.


Answer

Many people are installing CCTV in their properties as a home security measure as it has proved to be an effective tool in fighting crime. However the cameras are limited in what they are allowed to capture. This would include the owner's premises and such areas as to protect their property (e.g. car). If the camera is recording you, your family or your property and you believe that this is causing distress then you may wish to seek police advice.

However, it would be advisable, if you feel safe to do so, to speak to your neighbour to see if it is possible to move the camera so that it does not point at you or your property.


Answer

If the vendor told you that the perfume was Chanel and sold it to you as the original and you paid a reasonable price (so that you may not have been expected to realise that it was not genuine) then you should contact your local Trading Standards Office which will take up the complaint on your behalf. Although the vendor could be said to have obtained your money by a criminal deception, Trading Standards are the best people to deal with these matters.

See also the Citizens Advice's website.


Answer

Trespass to land is a civil matter and as such the police have no jurisdiction. Under common law, the landowner has a right to re-entry on the land; however the ejection of the trespasser is fraught with danger for the landowner. Initially, the landowner should ask the occupier to leave the land and if he/she does then all is well. The problems start however, if he/she refuses to leave the land.

It is also a criminal offence under the Trespass Scotland Act 1865 for a person to lodge in premises, occupy or encamp on any private property, without the consent and permission of the owner.

Anything done by a member of the public in exercising their access rights under the Land Reform Scotland Act 2003 does not amount to trespass. The Scottish Outdoor Access Code details these rights and how they should be exercised.

The owner of the land could commit several criminal offences if he forcibly removes the trespasser and his/her property from the land. The best and safest course of action is to obtain a court order, which if breached may then turn into a criminal matter.

If the police do attend an incident such as this, they are merely there as observers for any possible criminal offences committed by either party. The police cannot assist in the removal of the trespassers or their property from the land in question.

The police do have some powers against larger groups of occupiers if damage has been caused. Trespass is very complex and guidance should be sought where appropriate.


Answer

This is family law and as such the police have no jurisdiction over the matter. You need to seek further advice from your solicitor. It is likely that the case will go back before the court, who will decide what course of action to take.

However if you have concern for the safety of your child then you should contact Police Scotland by dialling 101 to instigate a missing person investigation.


Answer

CCTV cameras may be used for a number of purposes including:

  • The prevention, detection and investigation of crime;
  • Apprehension and / or prosecution of offenders (including images being entered as evidence in criminal proceedings)
  • Public and employee safety; and
  • Staff discipline.

If cameras are used then the shop/business must display a sign informing members of the public that cameras are in use, allowing an informed decision.

Organisations must comply with a Code of Practice which restricts the use of the data obtained. If you feel that your rights have been violated, then you need to make a complaint to the manager of the organisation or the Information Commissioner (see link in related information for more about Information Commissioner).


Answer

A cheque can be 'bounced' for a number of reasons which include:

  • insufficient funds in the account it's being drawn on,
  • it has been cancelled by the drawer (the person who wrote the cheque) or
  • a technical reason (unsigned, wrong date, amount etc)
  • fraud (maybe it is a stolen cheque).

Usually, if a cheque is 'bounced' the banking institution will write further instructions on the cheque such as 'Refer to Drawer Re-present' or 'Refer to drawer'.

If it states 'Refer to Drawer Re-present' then you can re-present the cheque again up to a maximum of 3 times although the bank does usually re-present the cheque before sending it back to you. Your bank may charge a fee for this.

If it states 'Refer to Drawer' then the cheque is effectively cancelled and cannot be re-presented. You need to get another cheque from the person or get them to give you cash.

If someone you do not know sends you a cheque then you should wait until it has cleared before drawing out the money or releasing any goods.

Be very clear when speaking to your bank about what you mean. The bank may allow you to draw funds on the cheque before it has cleared so should the cheque subsequently bounce you will be out of pocket.

When you speak to the bank about a cheque clearing, make sure they are aware that you mean that there is no danger of the cheque being returned unpaid and it has been honoured. The only way to really ensure that a cheque has been paid is to ask your bank to 'specially present' the cheque, there will be a charge for this and it may vary from bank to bank. If the cheque is a small amount then it may not be worthwhile but if it is a substantial amount and you are releasing goods then it could be beneficial.

If you suspect that a fraud has taken place then you should notify your bank who will advise you to report the matter to your local police station


Answer

The police may be able to assist in certain circumstances. They will not however get involved in civil property disputes and you should seek advice from a solicitor or Citizens Advice with regards to this.

If the other party agrees to your proposed action e.g. the collection of belongings, but you are concerned for your safety, contact your local Police Station. A police officer may check that the other party agrees to the proposed action and may explore alternatives e.g. meeting at a neutral location to exchange belongings. Where an alternative cannot be found a police officer may accompany you. If the other party does not agree to the proposed action, then it would be advisable not to attend and to contact a solicitor or Citizens Advice instead regarding alternative options.

Seek support from Victim Support and Advocacy Services

If you feel you are unable to make a report to Police for whatever reason, you can seek support and advice from victim support and advocacy services. Victim support and advocacy services are focused on reducing risk to and improving the safety of victims of domestic abuse. For more information on domestic abuse victim support and advocacy services, please visit the Police Scotland website.


Answer

If a road traffic accident/collision happened on a road or a public place and the other driver failed to stop or there are injuries then you have to report the accident to the police.

Some car parks can be classed as public places, for example, supermarket and multi story car parks. However, car parks belonging to private organisations where the members of the public would not ordinarily be permitted would not be classed as a public place and should be reported directly to your insurance company.


Answer

Unless the video or photo is of an indecent nature and of a child or of a criminal offence then the police will not get involved.

If the photo/video is for example, on one of the social networking websites, you could speak to the administrator of the internet site who may remove the material.

Otherwise, you would need to obtain a restraining order from the courts to order the removal of the material. You should seek advice from the Citizens Advice or a solicitor about this matter.


Answer

Getting the police involved in this type of issue is not always the best thing to do in the first instance, as it can escalate the issue and cause more problems for both parties.

The best thing to do, where possible, is to speak to your neighbour about the problem and try and resolve it between yourselves. If you have tried or feel that, for whatever reason, it is not an option then you should speak to your local community policing team.

If you keep the ball and refuse to give it back then you may eventually end up facing prosecution yourself.


Answer

In situations of this nature one person may have bought the vehicle, whilst the other may be shown as the registered keeper. This may give rise to a situation in which one person requires the other to return the vehicle and if they don't the person may allege they have stolen it. If this situation arises there are a number of points that you need to bear in mind:

Theft – in relation to theft, it is an offence for a person to dishonestly appropriate property belonging to another with the intention of depriving the other of it. It is not dishonest if a person has a genuine belief (the belief is a subjective test) that:

 

(a) He/she had a legal right to the property, whether a legal right exists or not is not the issue, or
(b) the other person would consent if he knew of the taking and the circumstances of it, or
(c) the owner could not be traced by taking reasonable steps, (a matter for a court to decide).

However, the vast majority of these cases are not theft. They are civil disputes and for this reason, we would initially suggest that you speak to a solicitor or someone from Citizens Advice Scotland via the link below:

http://www.cas.org.uk/

If they advise you to report the matter to the police, you can do so via the non-emergency 101 number.


Ownership of vehicle – whether a person is the owner of a vehicle is a question of fact for a court to decide. Relevant facts are the way the person treats/uses the vehicle, whether they have insurance for it and whether they have spent money on its purchase/upkeep etc. In the case of a car used by a married couple, ownership of any property is usually classed as joint. For an explanation of the difference between the 'owner' of a vehicle and the 'registered keeper' of a vehicle see the link below:

SQ743

Civil dispute - in a civil dispute over ownership of a car, if you are the legal owner of the vehicle and your ex has it, you can either require its return and seek a court order to this effect or sue them for its cost. You will need to seek legal advice from a solicitor to do this.

Police involvement – the police will only become involved in situations of this nature if a criminal offence has been/is about to be committed. Therefore, if your ex threatens you or you have been advised to report the matter as theft etc., you would be justified in calling the police on 101 for a non-emergency response or 999 for an emergency response.